CHOMSKY Archives

The philosophy, work & influences of Noam Chomsky

CHOMSKY@LISTSERV.ICORS.ORG

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Bill Bartlett <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Discussions on the writings and lectures of Noam Chomsky <[log in to unmask]>
Date:
Tue, 6 May 1997 13:03:29 +1100
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (261 lines)
At 1:45 PM 5/5/97, James W Hutchings wrote:


>> 5) Leninism

>.  All the revolutionary socialist groups that aren't anarchists
>are Leninist.

Hey! I've been left off the political map, I'm a revolutionary socialist,
here's a spiel from the SLP which closely approximates my views, it rejects
the general strike.
--------

POLITICAL GOVERNMENT SUITED AN EARLIER AGE

Two hundred years ago production was simple. Communities lived and worked
in isolation from one another. Artisans and farmers produced most of what
was consumed locally. Under those conditions a government based on
territory, with representatives elected from states and congressional
areas, made sense. It fit in with the economic and social conditions of the
times. Then things started to change.

Slowly at first, then rapidly after the Civil War, local production gave
way to national production and distribution. Transportation and
communications got better. The self- contained community disappeared, and
each came to depend on all the others for the goods they consumed.

Production and distribution are much more complicated today. Together with
modern communications and transportation, they form a web of connected
parts that cuts across all arbitrary boundary lines. Congress can't control
or direct any of this. Government based on territory is outdated. We need a
new form of government that fits in with modern conditions. We need a
democratic form of INDUSTRIAL GOVERNMENT.
---

SOCIALIST INDUSTRIAL UNIONISM--
THE WORKERS' POWER

There are times when social and economic problems become so bad that people
are forced to choose between the social system that makes their lives
difficult and a new one that will make their lives better. Times like that
are called revolutionary times. They don't come often, but when they do the
question of HOW to make the change that's needed becomes as important as
WHAT that change should be.

We face that kind of choice today. Capitalism--the social system we live
under--no longer serves the interests of the people. It creates countless
problems that it cannot solve. It uses technology to throw people out of
work and to make those who keep their jobs work harder. It creates hardship
and poverty for millions, while the few who own and control the economy
grow rich off the labor of those allowed to keep their jobs. It destroys
the cities that we built up. It is destroying the natural environment that
is the source of the food we eat and the air we breath.

Every effort made to prevent these problems, or to keep them from growing
even worse, has failed. The reason is that the country is controlled by a
small capitalist class that owns the industries and services that everyone
depends on. The workers built and they operate all of those essential
industries and services. However, they do not own and control them. They
are the majority, but they have no voice in deciding what to produce or how
much to produce. Their needs and desires count for nothing when those
decisions are made. When a small group owns and controls what everyone
needs to feed, house and clothe themselves and their families, when that
small group makes every important decision that affects the lives of the
vast majority, it is called despotism. CAPITALISM IS AN ECONOMIC DESPOTISM,
and like any other form of despotism, it spoils and corrupts everything
that is good and decent. Look at what it does to us.

Generations of workers built the industries that can produce more than
enough to wipe out poverty and guarantee the economic security of every
man, woman and child.

Capitalism has twisted this great achievement of labor's collective genius
by causing wealth and power to collect in the hands of a few. Technology
that could and should be used to lessen the need for arduous toil and to
enhance our lives is used instead to eliminate jobs and increase
exploitation. Poverty is as widespread as it has ever been. Wages go down
even as productivity rises. Joblessness, homelessness, helplessness and
despair are spreading. Economic insecurity and social breakdown place an
unbearable strain on our families, our children and ourselves. Emotional
stress, crime, prostitution, alcoholism, drug abuse, suicide, and many more
signs of unhappiness and hopelessness, are on the rise.

Is this what we want? Is this what we have worked so hard to build? Should
we keep a social system that is destroying the lives, the liberties and the
chance for happiness that our work and productivity make possible? Is it
really worth the price to keep a small and despotic class of capitalists
living in obscene wealth?

Or SHALL WE DO THE COMMON-SENSE THING, MAKE THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION OUR
COLLECTIVE PROPERTY, ABOLISH EXPLOITATION OF THE MANY BY THE FEW, AND USE
OUR PRODUCTIVE GENIUS TO CREATE SECURITY AND ABUNDANCE FOR ALL?

If you agree with us that the time for such a change has come, then there
are certain things we must understand. The first is that workers can expect
no help from the beneficiaries of capitalism. Individual capitalists may
see the handwriting on the wall and join with the workers. As a class,
however, the capitalists, just like the slave-owning and feudal classes
before them, will try to keep their strife-ridden and poverty- breeding
system. The workers can only rely on themselves to build a better world and
free themselves through their own classconscious efforts.

The second thing to understand is this: Workers make up the vast majority
of the population. By workers we mean the WORKING CLASS. We mean all whose
intellectual and physical labor contributes to the development, manufacture
and distribution of the goods, services and information that our complex
society needs. We mean all those who must sell their physical and mental
talents and skills on the labor market, and who depend on the wages and
salaries they receive in exchange. We mean white-collar and blue-collar,
production and office workers, those who research and develop as well as
those who build, distribute and serve. We mean the whole working class,
including the unemployed and those forced to settle for part- time or
temporary work.

THE WORKING CLASS MAKES EVERYTHING AND IT MAKES EVERYTHING WORK.
Collectively, it has tremendous POTENTIAL power. However, workers can apply
their collective strength only through organization.

How must they organize themselves?

First, they must form a political party of their own to assert their right
to make the change that's needed and to challenge the stranglehold the
ruling class has on the political government. That's what the American
colonists did in 1776 when they declared their right to "alter or to
abolish" a destructive government and to form a new one to serve their own
interests. They wrote that right or principle into our Constitution so we
could use it again whenever it became necessary. That's why the
Constitution has an amendment clause. It empowers the people to make any
change they deem necessary. In the language of Abraham Lincoln: "The right
of peaceable assembly and petition and by Article V of the
Constitution--the right of amendment--is the constitutional substitute for
[armed] revolution."

This means that the working class, by organizing a political party of its
own, can make full use of its constitutional rights to speak out for social
change, to explain the socialist program to all workers, and to vote for
the change they want. This is the civilized and nonviolent method. It
permits the forces of progress to declare their purpose in the open, and to
mobilize themselves for political victory and conquest of the capitalist
state.

However, no ruling class has ever willingly given up its power and
privileges. There is nothing in the history of our own ruling class to
indicate that it differs in this respect from the slave-owning and feudal
classes of old. Therefore, behind the socialist ballot the workers must
organize a power that is capable of enforcing its decision at the polls.
SOCIALIST INDUSTRIAL UNIONISM IS THAT POWER. Unlike AFL-CIO unionism, which
boasts of being a bulwark of capitalism, Socialist Industrial Unionism
declares its intention to abolish class rule.

Economic power is the source of all power. Modern armies cannot function
without a constant stream of goods and equipment that flow from the
industries. Although an army is a military power, it is dependent on the
industries; hence on the workers who operate the industries.

THE WORKING CLASS RUNS THE INDUSTRIES FROM TOP TO BOTTOM. The potential
economic power that rests in its hands is enormous. Properly organized into
Socialist Industrial Unions, that potential can become an irresistible
nonviolent force for social change. This is true because the WORKERS ARE IN
THE BEST STRATEGIC POSITION TO TAKE POSSESSION. "Taking possession" in an
orderly yet resolute manner is just what the working class must do the
moment that its victory is declared at the polls. This is not a general
strike that would lead the workers away from the source of their power and
leave them exposed on the open terrain. It is a GENERAL LOCKOUT OF THE
CAPITALIST CLASS!

Finally, the Socialist Industrial Union supplies the working class with the
democratic instrument needed to administer production under the Industrial
Republic of Labor. It is at once "the battering ram with which to pound
down the fortress of capitalism, and the successor of the capitalist social
structure itself."

ALL POWER TO THE SOCIALIST INDUSTRIAL UNION!
----------

SOCIALIST INDUSTRIAL UNIONISM

Under socialism all power to make social decisions will be vested in the people.

Our industries, their ownership, and how they are run are far more
important to our lives and welfare than any other aspect of our existence.
Socialist society and government will be based on these truths.
Accordingly:

The industries (the means of producing all goods and services) will be
owned collectively by all the people.

The industries will be administered democratically from bottom to top by
representatives elected directly by the workers in each industry and
subject to their control. All representatives will be subject to recall at
any time by those who elected them.

This industrial administration will, in fact, be the new government.

Production will be carried out to satisfy the people's wants. The useful
producers will receive in goods and services the social equivalent of their
work. Those unable to work will share in that abundance.

There in nothing in this picture which in any way resembles the workings of
class-divided capitalism and its political state.

The government of socialist America will have the job of coordinating and
administering our industrial activities. It will, accordingly, have an
INDUSTRIAL base. And it will be so constituted that all AUTHORITY will come
directly from THE WORKERS, integrally organized in Socialist Industrial
Unions.

In each plant (and in each school, hospital, etc.), the rank and file will
collectively determine workplace policies and will elect a committee to
plan the overall plant operations. In each subdivision of a plant, the
workers will participate in determining how best to implement the plans of
the committee and assure the efficient running of their economic unit.

Besides electing their immediate supervisors, the workers will also elect
representatives to local and national councils of their respective
industry--and to a central congress representing all the industries and
services.

This All-Industry Congress will ascertain what goods and services are
wanted and will determine the resources needed to supply them. It will draw
up the necessary production, expansion and improvement plans and allocate
these to the various industries. The congress will also arrange a
distribution of the output with the workers receiving the full social
equivalent of the labor they contributed.

All persons elected to posts in this economic administration, at whatever
level, will be subject to rank-and-file control, and to removal whenever a
majority of those who elected them find it desirable to replace them.

THIS is the only democracy POSSIBLE in highly industrialized America:
democracy founded on social ownership of the instruments of production and
distribution and on economic freedom. It is the only form of society that
can solve the problems capitalism has imposed upon us. It is the only
social structure that can release the abundance for all now locked up in
the capitalist economy.

For you as an individual, socialist industrial democracy will mean a full,
happy and useful life. It will mean the opportunity to develop all your
talents. It will mean direct participation in the decisions of a society of
free human beings.

In socialist society, class divisions and exploitation will have been
eliminated. Production will be carried out for use by all rather than to
serve the profit interests of a small minority. There would be no "crises
of overproduction," no unemployment due to the accumulation by a ruling
class of commodities that workers could not afford to buy.

The only limit on production would be social needs and wants. The
allocation of resources will be democratically planned by a society in full
control of its productive forces.

In socialist society, for the first time, the people will consciously
direct their economic activity and democratically provide for their own
well-being and security. Not only useful labor, but the fruits of that
labor as well, will be available to all.

The principles of workers' democracy--i.e., the right and power of the
majority to recall all elected representatives, the abolition of
bureaucratic privileges, etc.--would ensure that control of the socialist
industrial government remained in the hands of the rank and file.

ATOM RSS1 RSS2