CELIAC Archives

Celiac/Coeliac Wheat/Gluten-Free List

CELIAC@LISTSERV.ICORS.ORG

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Susan Carmack <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Susan Carmack <[log in to unmask]>
Date:
Sat, 6 Nov 2004 22:07:26 -0800
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (103 lines)
<<Disclaimer: Verify this information before applying it to your situation.>>

Never mind age........my neighbour was diagnosed in her eighties. Many
doctors don't know enough about celiac.......Victor, Timmins, ON (home of
Shania twain and she is here to-day to celebrate the opening of the Shania
twain Centre)_
*****************
Ha! I was recently diagnosed at 52 and I am overweight. So much for that
theory
******************
We had a doctor down here in Ohio who told a 50 year old woman she was too
old.  According to the NIH, the middle aged person is the one being
diagnosed the most!!

I fired a letter off to that doctor informing her of the misconception, and
also told her that to refuse a test to anyone just prolongs that patient's
suffering.

The ones who should be staying current on things (the M.D.'s)...just don't
seem to be.  Guess they figured whatever they learned in medical school
still stands.
   *******************
I was overweight and so were 4 of my family members when we were dxd.
********************
YES! They should be eating a GLUTEN-RICH diet or testing will be
inaccurate. Peter green and Alessio Fassano both recommend this.
**********************
Now you know why people diagnose themselves. Doctors are so impossible
(most of them)
One has to eat heavily on gluten before tests even then there are so many
false negatives
So they are looking for the classic symptoms thin and etc...and too old
that's pure crazy
   I live on tpn; too late a diagnosis.  I do have a great doctor took a
long time to find him.
Even  a person that weighs 400 lbs can have celiac disease.
********************
First of all, the biopsies are not 100% correct even if a person is eating
only gluten for years, let alone not eating it at all or eating very
little.  My doctor took 12 biopsies of me and all 12 were celiac, (long
story as to why so many biopsies were done), but I was told that when they
select tissue to be biopsied, they need to take a number of samples,
because not all are usually positive.  Most docs do not do this--I have
heard of docs who only do 1 to 3.  In your friends' cases, besides this,
most likely some of their gut damage was already healing due to being
gf.  SO, no positive dx.

Secondly, I was overweight when I was dxed.  I was shown research by my doc
that showed that about 1/3 of all celiacs are overweight at  dx, contrary
to common medical opinion on the subject.  Thirdly, NOBODY can be too
old!  That is just absurd!  Tell your friends to ditch the quack and find a
REAL doctor!  lol

I frankly don't even think many people should try to get a dx of celiac
disease.  I have one and, for all intents and purposes, it is
useless.  None of the docs I have seen since dx even consider my celiac
disease.  Heaven help me if I have to be hospitalized, as I will have to
bring in my own team of medical experts just to get the hospital to comply
with my gf diet!  If I had known to go gf on my own, and I already was gf,
there is no way I'd be searching for a dx.  I'd just keep on keeping on
with the gf diet.
***********************
We had to be persistent, because no one had obvious or extreme
symptoms except dad. My daughter had two false negatives at one lab
before a more experienced lab recognized the more subtle changes of
earlier celiac. I am a firm advocate for screening in all at-risk
people, regardless of their symptoms. My niece went to a GI pediatric
specialist and was told she had "abdominal migraines" and blew off
the possibility of celiac despite the fact that he knew her
grandfather & aunt (me) had celiac. Upon biopsy, her Villi were flat.

I DO think the awareness is growing, but docs are still very ignorant
in their own little worlds! :o)
*****************
Never mind age........my neighbour was diagnosed in her eighties. Many
doctors don't know enough about celiac.......Victor, Timmins, ON (home of
Shania twain and she is here to-day to celebrate the opening of the Shania
twain Centre)_
*****************
Ha! I was recently diagnosed at 52 and I am overweight. So much for that
theory
******************
We had a doctor down here in Ohio who told a 50 year old woman she was too
old.  According to the NIH, the middle aged person is the one being
diagnosed the most!!

I fired a letter off to that doctor informing her of the misconception, and
also told her that to refuse a test to anyone just prolongs that patient's
suffering.

The ones who should be staying current on things (the M.D.'s)...just don't
seem to be.  Guess they figured whatever they learned in medical school
still stands.
  *******************
I was overweight and so were 4 of my family members when we were dxd.
********************
YES! They should be eating a GLUTEN-RICH diet or testing will be
inaccurate. Peter green and Alessio Fassano both recommend this.
*********************
More to come!

*Support summarization of posts, reply to the SENDER not the CELIAC List*

ATOM RSS1 RSS2