I wondered about that. Pat Barrett ----- Original Message ----- From: "william" <[log in to unmask]> To: <[log in to unmask]> Sent: Sunday, May 03, 2009 10:24 AM Subject: Re: Cordain > Kenneth Anderson wrote: > >> >> You seem to have found a diet that works for you and your specific >> situation. Should all other diets, even the researched diets, be >> rejected? I think Cordain makes a general definition of how Paleo >> people lived and eat, he doesn't seem to center on any one region or >> people. >> > > I tried other diets, including Cordain's, which is BTW Neolithic. His is > better than SAD, but that does not make it paleolithic. > > He ignores the evidence that those who try what we believe is a true > paleodiet succeed in regaining health, while others fail. > He ignores the studies in "Good Calories Bad Calories" which show that low > fat is nonsense. > > A scientist who ignores evidence is not respectable, and I cannot trust > him. > > William