On Mon, 22 Oct 2007 21:06, Todd Moody wrote: >> The New York Times (who published Taubes' original article) >> reviewed the book a fortnight ago. They regarded it as >> sloppily researched and ignoring inconvenient but >> well-substantiated evidence that did not fit Taubes' thesis. >> >> Any comments on that from those who have read it? >> >> Keith > >I haven't read the NYT review, so I can't comment on the >particulars, but "sloppily researched" doesn't fit at all. >Todd Moody >[log in to unmask] Here's a link to the New York Times' review: http://tinyurl.com/2tnzlk Keith