----- "william" <[log in to unmask]> wrote: 
> Todd Moody wrote: 
> > 
> > After regaining a lot of weight, I tried an all-meat zero carb diet for a couple of months. I found that I was compelled to eat very large amounts of meat, frequently. My appetite was huge. I didn't lose much weight, if any, in the course of two months of this. That is, my appetite and body composition remained out of equilibrium, or out of sync, if you prefer. Does that prove that there's something "wrong" with the zero carb diet? 
> 
> It proves that there is something wrong with a cooked (and low animal 
> saturated fat?) zero carb diet, if that is what you tried. 

Cooked, yes; low animal fat, no. In any case, it proves nothing of the sort. A single case can never prove a generalization. As you know well, there are plenty of people who thrive on diets of cooked zero carb foods. I just happened not to be one of them. There is simply no justification for concluding that my failure trumps their success. 

Todd Moody