> I don't understand the reasonning here. If the risk of an alternative
> treatment ( like olive oil for ex.) to surgery is ending up in surgery
> anyway, what is the difference.?
> At least you have chances to pass those stones without  the surgery
because
> i heard account of peoples having  success with getting rid of stones.

Often the gallbladder is already peramanently scarred(especially if there
have been painful attacks) and diseased and will be unable to contract, or
if it did will still get infected.  The alternative is not safe and is
painful.
If someone has something broken, it cannot always be fixed.
I like your logic, but sometimes, reason must give way to experience.
If one were to adopt a natural therapy, why expel the spone in a violent
exorcism- let it slowly dissolve away- after all, if your diet cannot
achieve that, then the stones will only reform after expulsion. If one will
not change the diet for life, the stones will recur- one may as well submit
to the scalpel- which is much easier these days because of keyhole surgery.
The best diet is still only a guess.

>
> I am myself not into therapeutique approach in general ( except in case of
> emergency , and even there some doctors see emergency where there is
none),
> and will rather trust the ability of the body to resolve the problemes  on
> its own, once the processus of creating them have been adressed and
> corrected. In fact ( at least in my eyes) the creation of stones is the
> body's healing  response to the conditions that created them in the 1 st
> place. that made them necessary to be formed.
> Could our  bodies  survive the abuse inflicted to them if their capacity
to
> make stones, cystes, tumors, to collaborate with parasites viruses, and
> bacterias will not allow the organism to keep functionning ( sometimes to
> the point of no retour, i will agree)?
>
> >
> >Sorry Arthur, you're stuck with them. If your doctor say that you don't
> need
> >an operation yet, then just maybe the right diet may see them dissolve
> >slowly over several years. What is the right diet? - well, if you find
out
> >please tell me. A high vegetable paleo diet may be good, but that's just
a
> >guess.
> >Above all, take your doctor's advice.
>
> I dealt with doctors enough in my life to be more prudent about following
> their advices. I think it is important to be able to hear what they see in
a
> specifique situation, but from there to do what they want you to do ,there
> is a world of (other ) possibilities. Specially knowing that doctors are
the
> most fearfull peoples  in front of death and suffering that i met.( it is
> why there are so keen and  in a hurry to cure symptoms) They are not into
> the healing business, healing require more courage than that.
> It require to accept our vulnerability  , to endorse the full
responsibility
> of our own actions.
> I am going a little bit farther even: There is only one true cure of
disease
> ....,it is DEATH  Any body who pretend selling cure to disease is lying
 to
> him or herself in 1st place).
>
> I am going to stop, before peoples throw stones at me.
> Sorry i had to say it
> jean-claude