PALEOFOOD Archives

Paleolithic Eating Support List

PALEOFOOD@LISTSERV.ICORS.ORG

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Amadeus Schmidt <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Paleolithic Eating Support List <[log in to unmask]>
Date:
Mon, 6 Dec 1999 14:09:32 +0100
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (138 lines)
Vitamins, especialls B vitamins are one of my favourite subjects.
B vitamins cannot be considered as a whole.
Each one is required itself, they just need
each other's peresence to work best.

Troy G. wrote:
>If you eat plenty of meat--including organ meats--
>you will get plenty  of B
>vitamins.
Troy is right, but you'll have to eat real *plenty* of meat
and plenty of organ meats too to get sufficient some.
Liver is a very good vitamin A source, and a reasonable good source
of B vitamins. The amounts needed (especially of the potentially
dangerous liver) are realy enormous - at least in my point of view.
Look at the data below, I compiled.

Mary <moira–INOW.COM> wrote:
>...

>But if the child is on a paleo diet, wouldnt' he/she be getting enough
b's
>if they are getting lots of meat??
>
>even if their absorption was not quite as good as others?
>
>Just wondering. I'm giving mine dried liver right now for b's
You seem to consider a high meat diet as "the" paleo diet.
But meats are generally *no* rich source of B-vitamins (except B2).
Liver is the only meat of higher contents because liver is the (animal)
bodie's storage organ for some vitamins.
But its not a good source of choice, because it's too high in vitamin A
(as repeatedly discussed and as Richard mentiones).
How much dried liver (from how much fresh liver) would you
give to your kid *every day* ? For enough folate, niacin or thiamin?

Try *200* grams of liver.
 vitA (IU)   71358    5000 1427.16%
 vitC (mg)      46      60   76.67%
 Thia (mg)     0.4     1.5   26.67%
 Ribo (mg)     8.2     1.7  482.35%
  Nia (mg)   21.44      19  112.84%
 Chol (mg)     778     300  259.33%
 Folate       about         200.00%
 B6           about          100%
Even if the vitamin A wasn't toxic (14-fold!) it was just enough
for the niacin (112%) and C(76%) - b2 as expected plenty.
Even then the Thiamin is rather low(25%).

How much vitamin-A overdose would you risk?

Now try that with normal beef.
Who's child eats a whole pound of beef?

Here are the results of the one pound for a kid (10 y o).
   Nutri     Total    Rec.   %Rec.
-----------+--------+------+------
   Pro (g)  135.62      28  484.36%
 Iron (mg)   13.61      10   136.1%
   Na (mg)  299.37    2000   14.97%
 Phos (mg) 1047.79     800  130.97%
 vitA (IU)       0    3500       0%
 vitC (mg)       0      45       0%
 Thia (mg)    0.41       1      41%
 Ribo (mg)    1.09     1.2   90.83%
  Nia (mg)   18.14      13  139.54%
Folate is about  15.7  160    10%
B6     is about   .9    1.8   50%
Even in this amount some B vitamins may be plenty,
others are still low.
The challenge is to find adequate food items providing the rest.

Todd Moody wrote:
>
>But yes, a kid on a paleo diet that includes liver is probably
>getting enough B vitamins for normal human metabolic purposes.
Todd, how much meat and liver would you give to the kid?
200 grams of liver *every day*?
1 pound of beef *every day*?

Richard Archer <rha–JUGGERNAUT.COM.AU> wrote:
>There are other organ meats high in Vit B, and with a better
>vitamin A balance. Kidney, for example, is very well-balanced.
>I find the taste of kidney less disagreeable than liver, too.
>Pancreas has a good balance too, although I have no idea what
>it tastes like :(

Say, Richard, do you have the possibility to sort food items
by ingredient (e.g. niacin?). And to exclude unwanted items
- unpaleo unnatural or composite items?
That would be handy looking after the *natural* providers of essentials.
I *can* sort by ingredient (per weight only).
But niacin isn't included.
On the net I never found an ingredient searcher except
http://www.mymenus.com/nutr13.htm    but they sort their own menues
only. Unpaleo. Unable to distinguish the sources.
I include such a hardcopy just for your "inspiration" ;-)

regards
Amadeus S.

hardcopy for
Richard:
™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™
„                 Lebensmittel mit mehr wie   0.0 mg  Vit. B6


„
„      Etwa  1.6 mg Vit. B6 pro Tag werden empfohlen (Frau, 36-50 Jahre)


„
ΎŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
„     1  Weizen Kleie                       2.2 mg/100 g    10.8 mg/1000
„     2  Fluίkrebs (Edelkrebs) gegart       2.1 mg/100 g    26.6 mg/1000
„     3  Weizen Keim                        2.0 mg/100 g     5.4 mg/1000
„     4  Banane getrocknet                  1.2 mg/100 g     4.3 mg/1000
„     5  Sardine gerδuchert                 1.0 mg/100 g     4.3 mg/1000
„     6  Gemόsepaprika gelb frisch          1.0 mg/100 g    10.0 mg/1000
„     7  Lachs frisch                       1.0 mg/100 g     4.4 mg/1000
„     8  Bachsaibling frisch                1.0 mg/100 g     9.1 mg/1000
„     9  Lachs gerδuchert                   1.0 mg/100 g     3.1 mg/1000
„    10  Zwiebeln getrocknet                1.0 mg/100 g     3.6 mg/1000
„    11  Hafer ganzes Korn                  1.0 mg/100 g     2.5 mg/1000
„    12  Leinsamen frisch                   0.9 mg/100 g     1.8 mg/1000
„    13  Kartoffelchips                     0.9 mg/100 g     1.6 mg/1000
„    14  Bauernbratwurst                    0.9 mg/100 g     2.2 mg/1000
„    15  Kartoffelbreipulver                0.8 mg/100 g     2.4 mg/1000
„    16  Kartoffelkloί gekocht Trockenpro   0.8 mg/100 g     2.4 mg/1000
„    17  Kalb Innereien gegart              0.8 mg/100 g     5.3 mg/1000
„    18  Kalb Leber gegart                  0.8 mg/100 g     5.3 mg/1000
„    19  Walnuί europδisch                  0.8 mg/100 g     1.1 mg/1000
     20  Hirse ganzes Korn                  0.8 mg/100 g     2.5 mg/1000

™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™™

--
Sent through Global Message Exchange - http://www.gmx.net

ATOM RSS1 RSS2