---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Sun, 11 Aug 2002 13:57:57 -0500
From: Africa Action <[log in to unmask]>
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Africa: Treatment Access Updates
Africa: Treatment Access Updates
Date distributed (ymd): 020811
Document reposted by Africa Action
Africa Policy Electronic Distribution List: an information
service provided by AFRICA ACTION (incorporating the Africa
Policy Information Center, The Africa Fund, and the American
Committee on Africa). Find more information for action for
Africa at http://www.africaaction.org
+++++++++++++++++++++Document Profile+++++++++++++++++++++
Region: Continent-Wide
Issue Areas: +health+ +economy/development+
SUMMARY CONTENTS:
At the XIV International AIDS Conference in Barcelona in July,
there was little dissent to the overwhelming consensus that
treatment (including anti-retroviral treatment) as well as
prevention were indispensable and interlinked means to combat the
AIDS pandemic. In practical terms, however, only about 30,000
Africans are estimated to be receiving anti-retroviral treatment,
while the death toll is over 2 million a year. Post-conference,
officials in many countries are still placing practical stumbling
blocks in the way of the massive expansion in treatment access that
is urgently needed.
This posting contains several short updates on policy in South
Africa, the U.S., and Kenya. Notably, South African mining company
giant has now pledged to make full treatment available for its
workers. But some South African officials still seem to be fighting
rear-guard actions against expanding treatment, even for
prevention of mother-to-child transmission. U.S. pressure for new
bureaucratic procedures is reported to be blocking quick
distribution of Global Fund grants already approved. And in Kenya,
an anonymously-inserted amendment in the Industrial Property Act
has blocked efforts to step up imports of generic medicines. For
more details see the excerpts and sources cited below.
+++++++++++++++++end profile++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
SOUTH AFRICA
(1) Mining Conglomerate Anglo American to Provide Antiretroviral
Therapy to HIV-Positive Employees in Southern Africa
Excerpted from: Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, Aug. 6, 2002
http://www.kaisernetwork.org/dailyreports/hiv
E-mail: [log in to unmask]
Mining company Anglo American today announced that it will provide
antiretroviral therapy to its HIV-positive employees in Southern
Africa who do not already qualify for treatment under medical aid
schemes, Reuters reports. Through its subsidiaries AngloGold and
DeBeers, the company employs about 90,000 people in the region
(Gush, Reuters, 8/6). An estimated 23% of its workforce -- or
18,000 people -- is HIV-positive, company spokesperson Anne Dunn
said. ... Anglo did not provide an overall cost estimate for the
program, but Dunn said the company expects to spend about $165 per
qualifying HIV-positive employee per year to provide antiretroviral
therapy, counseling and treatment for side effects from the
antiretroviral drugs. ...
Last month, AngloGold signed an agreement with five labor unions in
South Africa to develop strategies to lessen the impact of HIV/AIDS
on its workforce (Agence France-Presse, 8/6). ... AngloGold
estimated that HIV/AIDS is costing its South African mining
operations between $4 and $6 per ounce of gold produced. The
company estimated that the cost could rise to $9 per ounce if no
measures are taken to help its workforce. Anglo said that the new
program will lower costs by reducing absenteeism and reducing
medical expenses and pension benefits in the long run (Reuters,
8/6).
For the Anglo American press release see:
http://www.angloamerican.co.uk/press/2002/06082002.asp
(2) South African Medicines Control Council Reviewing Safety and
Efficacy of Nevirapine
[From: Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, August 6, 2002]
South Africa's Medicines Control Council last week announced that
it is conducting a review of its approval of the antiretroviral
drug nevirapine, which is used to prevent mother-to-child HIV
transmission, due to "serious concerns" about the drug's safety and
efficacy, the South Africa Sunday Times reports. Two weeks ago,
members of the MCC asked representatives from Boehringer Ingelheim,
the drug's manufacturer, to explain several deaths allegedly linked
to the drug during a Ugandan study and why the company had decided
to withdraw a U.S. application for approval to market the drug as
a treatment for the prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission
(Jubasi, South Africa Sunday Times, 8/4). Boehringer pulled its FDA
application in March after FDA regulators said they uncovered
problems with a 1999 study performed in Uganda by Johns Hopkins
University researchers. The questions related to procedure and not
the validity of the study, which found that use of the drug during
childbirth can reduce HIV transmission to infants (Kaiser Daily
HIV/AIDS Report, 3/25). Precious Matsoso, the registrar of the
council, said the MCC is reviewing Boehringer's "compliance" with
the South African Medicines Control Act and will issue a final
report in September. If the company is found to be in violation of
the act, the MCC can ask it to withdraw the drug's registration.
...(South Africa Sunday Times, 8/4).
Advocates Accuse MCC of 'Losing Its Independence'
HIV/AIDS advocates said the MCC's review of nevirapine raised
concerns about the board's motivation and signaled that it was
"losing its independence," the South African Press Association
reports. "There is overwhelming evidence that nevirapine is safe
for [preventing] mother-to-child transmission. Not a single serious
side effect has been reported when nevirapine has been used for
this purpose," Nathan Geffen, national manager of the Treatment
Action Campaign, said, adding that his group is "very concerned"
that Matsoso and MCC Chair Peter Eagles are "not acting on the
basis of ensuring access to safe and effective medicine, but rather
with political motivation." He accused the two of trying to
"scuttle" the implementation of a court order that requires the
government to provide antiretroviral treatment to all HIV-positive
pregnant women at public hospitals to reduce the odds of vertical
transmission. Nevirapine is the most commonly used drug for this
purpose, and the withdrawal of its registration could create a
"nightmare" for MTCT programs in the country, SAPA reports. ...
(SAPA, 8/4).
(3) URGENT JOINT STATEMENT ON GLOBAL FUND ALLOCATION TO
KWAZULU-NATAL
1 August 2002
The following is a joint statement by the following organisations
and individuals:
Archbishop Njongonkulu Ndungane; South African Medical Association;
Southern African HIV Clinicians Society; South African Academy of
Family Practice/Primary Care; Diakonia Council of Churches; AIDS
Consortium; AIDS Law Project; Children's Rights Centre; Durban Gay
and Lesbian Community and Health Centre; Southern African Fogarty
AIDS Training Programme; Professor Hoosen Coovadia, Victor Daitz
Professor of HIV/AIDS Research,University of Natal Durban;
Professor Quarraisha Abdool-Karim, University of Natal Durban;
SANGOCO - KZN; SANCO - KZN; Treatment Action Campaign
For further information, please contact:
Loraine Tulleken (Archbishop Ndungane's media liason officer) 011
839 1058; Nonkosi Khumalo (TAC Executive Secretary) 072 2311 422 or
021 788 3507
Centre for Civil Society, University of Natal, Durban, South
Africa, http://www.nu.ac.za/ccs
DECLARATION OF SUPPORT FOR FUNDING OF THE KWAZULU-NATAL ENHANCING
CARE INITIATIVE
HIV/AIDS In KwaZulu-Natal (KZN)
One in 4 people in KZN live with HIV/AIDS. It is the worst-affected
province in South Africa and one of the worst in the world. Already
there is immense suffering and death, especially among poor people,
and the public health system in the province is struggling to cope
with the burden of this disease. If nothing is done, the situation
will become much worse.
Enhancing Care Initiative KZN Is a Crucial Step Towards Alleviating
the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
The Enhancing Care Initiative KwaZulu-Natal (ECI KZN), in response
to two years of research performed in the communities of KZN,
brought forward a comprehensive proposal for prevention, care and
support for people with HIV/AIDS in the province. It is a joint
project by researchers from the Nelson Mandela Medical School of
the University of Natal Durban, the KZN Department of Health, the
Durban Chamber of Commerce, the National Association of People
Living with AIDS (NAPWA) and many other organisations and
institutions, both local and international. It includes a
comprehensive range of prevention, care and support interventions
for combating the HIV epidemic, including vertical transmission
prevention of the virus, and highly active antiretroviral therapy.
These crucial interventions will save lives and help prevent new
infections.
During its initial stages, the ECI KZN project will offer
antiretroviral therapy to a fraction of people with HIV who need
treatment, but its most important value will be to establish an
example of how such treatment can be carried out in South Africa
and other developing countries, so that ultimately millions of
people in need of life-saving medicines for HIV/AIDS will receive
them. To facilitate this, part of the ECI KZN proposal is to assist
other provinces and neighbouring countries to apply for funding
from the Global Fund in the next call for proposals due on the 27th
September 2002.
The antiretroviral projects established by the ECI KZN will be a
necessary part of the implementation of a treatment plan for
HIV/AIDS and will be a first step to secure the comprehensive
provision of antiretrovirals in the province and country-wide. By
the fifth year of the ECI KZN implementation, it is envisaged that
most public health care facilities in the province will offer
antiretroviral treatment via clinics treating Tuberculosis and
vertical transmission prevention programmes. This is therefore a
critical step in the effort to reverse the HIV/AIDS epidemic.
Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria
The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria (Global
Fund) is an unprecedented international effort to raise funds for
developing countries to fight these diseases. The Global Fund has
agreed to fund the ECI KZN approximately R700 million (U$D 72
million) over five years.
Unfortunately, there is a dispute between the National Minister of
Health, the Global Fund and the ECI KZN over this funding. This is
an unnecessary controversy that is damaging South Africa's
reputation with the Global Fund and the international community.
More importantly, it is causing a delay in the implementation of
the ECI KZN which will result in further unnecessary AIDS deaths
and new HIV infections. We, the undersigned organisations and
individuals are deeply concerned and desire that a just end be
brought to this controversy immediately.
End the Controversy. Ensure Global Fund Money Goes to ECI KZN .
We welcome the Global Fund's acceptance of the ECI KZN proposal and
congratulate all parties involved in the ECI KZN for the effort
they have made to bring it about. In particular, we welcome the
leadership role played by the KZN Department of Health with regard
to the ECI KZN. We are satisfied that given the constraints under
which the proposal was made, it was developed through a reasonable
consultative process. When the proposal was sent to the Global Fund
for approval, no legally or materially functioning country
co-ordinating mechanism representing the interests of people with
HIV/AIDS existed in South Africa for managing the epidemic. Such a
mechanism still does not exist. If it did exist this controversy
might have been avoided.
The Cabinet statement of 17 April on HIV/AIDS was welcomed by all
sectors of South African society and by the international community
as a clear indication that the National Government will lead the
fight against HIV/AIDS. It is now necessary for the National
Department of Health to demonstrate its commitment to the
implementation of the Cabinet statement. It can do this by:
* Unconditionally endorsing the ECI KZN and allowing the proposal
to be implemented as it stands.
* Reconstituting the South African National AIDS Council (SANAC) as
a legal, functioning, independent entity that truly represents the
interests of people with HIV/AIDS and seeks representation from all
sectors of South African society with a real interest in
alleviating the HIV/AIDS epidemic.
* Facilitating further proposals to the Global Fund from South
Africa and each of its provinces.
Let Us Work Together Against the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
We urge all sectors of South African society to work together to
ensure the successful implementation of the ECI KZN. We therefore
ask the National Department of Health and all other parties
involved to ensure the speedy delivery of Global Fund money
allocated to the ECI KZN.
In the words of the 17 April Cabinet Statement, let us join hands
in a campaign of hope. Our combined efforts are essential if we are
to defeat the HIV/AIDS epidemic.
(4) Mandela and Mbeki Meet to Discuss Provision of Antiretroviral
Drugs for South Africans
[From: Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, August 5, 2002]
Former South African President Nelson Mandela met with South
African President Thabo Mbeki Thursday night to discuss the
country's role in providing antiretroviral treatment to
HIV-positive people, but the two parties agreed not to disclose
what was said during the meeting, the South African Press
Association reports. Mandela formally requested a meeting with
Mbeki on the issue last Monday, following Mandela's meeting with
Treatment Action Campaign Chair Zackie Achmat. Achmat, who is
HIV-positive, is refusing to take antiretroviral drugs until they
are made available to all South Africans who need them (South
African Press Association, 8/2). Antiretroviral drugs are "freely
available" to South Africans who have private medical insurance,
including Achmat, but are not available in state hospitals, which
treat most of the country's residents. The South African government
has said that the drugs are too costly to give to all HIV-positive
South Africans (Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, 7/29).
************************************************************
USA
[From: Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, August 5, 2002]
(1) Bush Administration Demands Stalling Distribution of Grants
From Global AIDS Fund
Although it has approved $1.6 billion in grants for programs in
more than 40 countries, the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis
and Malaria has not yet distributed any money, largely because of
"demands led by the Bush administration" that the fund create an
aid-delivery mechanism "from scratch," the Wall Street Journal
reports. The Global Fund has so far received $2.1 billion in
pledges; the United States has pledged $500 million of this amount.
The fund approved 58 project applications in its first round,
including $165.3 million for programs in South Africa and $92.9
million for efforts in Zambia -- two countries with HIV prevalence
rates of more than 20%. As the HIV/AIDS pandemic continues to grow,
the fund is facing "mounting pressure" to distribute the grants.
Global Fund Executive Director Richard Feachem said that he hopes
to distribute money to a "handful" of projects by October, although
this deadline is also "up in the air," the Journal reports. Most of
the grant recipients will not receive any money until the end of
the year or later.
Creating a New Distribution System
The Journal reports that several donors to the fund, including the
United States and the United Kingdom -- are "dubious" about
allocating aid through existing agencies, such as the United
Nations and the World Bank. The Bush administration and the U.K.
government say that existing agencies have not had enough of a
"positive effect" and are asking that the Global Fund "shun
existing aid agencies and build its own system," a request that has
delayed the distribution of funding. Despite the United States'
objections, the World Bank holds the fund's money and has agreed to
wire grants to recipients. To create its own distribution
mechanism, the fund must implement its own procurement,
administrative, auditing and other services in each country for
each grant. ... U.S. officials concede that creating this approach
will mean "somewhat slower delivery of the aid," but they say that
closer monitoring of aid distribution will ensure a greater
benefit. ... Feachem and U.S. and British officials say that the
fund is making "quick progress" in implementing its new
distribution system, but "tension has emerged" between donors and
the recipients who want to receive the money as soon as possible.
Milly Katana, a Ugandan AIDS activist who represents private
charities on the fund's board, said, "I don't see any justification
for that kind of excess precaution. ... lives are being lost"
(Phillips, Wall Street Journal, 8/5).
(2) Bush Signs FY 2002 Supplemental Spending Bill, Has 30 Days to
Decide on Contingency Funds, Including $200M for Global AIDS
President Bush on [Aug.2] signed a $28.9 billion fiscal year 2002
supplemental spending bill (HR 4775) that includes $200 million for
international HIV/AIDS programs, CongressDaily reports. However, it
is not clear whether the HIV/AIDS funding will be released because
it is included as part of a $5 billion contingency package that
must be approved separately. Bush has 30 days to decide whether to
authorize the contingency funds (Ghent/Koffler, CongressDaily,
8/2). If he fails to make a declaration on the measure, all of the
emergency funding, including the $200 million for HIV/AIDS, would
be lost. Bush has not indicated whether he will approve the funding
(Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, 7/25).
************************************************************
KENYA
UN Integrated Regional Information Network
http://www.irinnews.org
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United
Nations]
NAIROBI, 5 August (IRIN) - Pressure is mounting on the Kenyan
government to re-amend the Industrial Property Act to allow for
the importation of generic anti-retroviral medicines (ARVs) into
the country, as parliament prepares to go into recess until
October at the end of this week.
The Industrial Property Act, which became law on 1 May 2002,
allowed for the importation of any drugs into Kenya which were
registered, and therefore legally available, in another country.
In the case of ARVs - a lifeline for those who are HIV positive or
have AIDS - this means a difference in price of 2,000 Kenyan
shillings (US $26) per month for generic drugs from India, as
opposed to 8,000 shillings for patented drugs (currently available)
produced by international pharmaceutical companies.
However, on 7 June, an amendment was made to section 58 of
the act, which made it mandatory to seek the "express consent"
of the original patent holders of the drugs before importing, the
Daily Nation reported on 25 July. Campaigners agree that such
permission - to effectively undercut the bigger pharmaceutical
companies - is highly unlikely to be granted.
Meanwhile, the ministers for trade and health, and the
attorney-general - whose office is responsible for the drafting of
all bills - have denied any involvement in the amendment. "It
cannot be pinpointed exactly who was responsible for amending
the section, but the matter has been raised with the
attorney-general," the Kenyan newspaper Daily Nation quoted
Health Minister Sam Ongeri as telling parliament.
"This is the first time in Kenyan history that an amendment to a
law has been made without the instigation of a ministry," Newton
Kulundu, chairman of the parliamentary health committee, told
PlusNews. "None of them liked to admit responsibility," he added.
The Kenya Coalition on Access to Essential Medicines (KCAEM),
an umbrella group of campaigners, is seeking to have the act
re-amended to its original wording, Robert Lettington, legal
consultant for the Coalition, said. If this is not possible before
parliament goes into recess (which may be delayed until next
week due to outstanding issues), another alternative would be for
the government to issue an interim order, which would effectively
nullify the disputed amendment, until the original wording is
reinstated.
Kulundu told PlusNews that parliament was due to discuss the
matter this week, and added that Ongeri had been put under
"intense pressure" to name those responsible for the amendment.
While the debate rages over responsibility, however, ordinary
people continue to suffer. The United Nations estimates that 700
people die of HIV/AIDS and related illnesses in Kenya each day,
and only 6,000 people have access to ARVs.
Lisa Kyambo of Cry for the World said not everyone would be able
to afford the 2,000 shillings per month for the generic ARVs, but
that it would certainly make them a lot more widely available.
"It's a progressive thing. They used to cost US $1,000 per month,
now they cost about US $100, and we are pushing to get them for US
$25."
If the re-amendment to the Property Act were to be effected,
pressure on the government would also result in the generic ARVs
being widely available in Kenya within two to three months, she
added.
In the meantime, the KCAEM is exploring possible courses of
action to take. "At the very least, the amendment was made in a
very unorthodox manner," Lettington said. "Its legality is a bigger
question. We are exploring our legal options in terms of the
constitution and whether the amendment would be considered
constitutional or not."
************************************************************
This material is being reposted for wider distribution by
Africa Action (incorporating the Africa Policy Information
Center, The Africa Fund, and the American Committee on Africa).
Africa Action's information services provide accessible
information and analysis in order to promote U.S. and
international policies toward Africa that advance economic,
political and social justice and the full spectrum of human rights.
Documents previously distributed, as well as a wide range of
additional information, are also available on the Web at:
http://www.africaaction.org
To be added to or dropped from the distribution list write to
[log in to unmask] For more information about reposted material,
please contact directly the source mentioned in the posting.
Africa Action
110 Maryland Ave. NE, #508, Washington, DC 20002.
Phone: 202-546-7961. Fax: 202-546-1545.
E-mail: [log in to unmask]
************************************************************
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
To unsubscribe/subscribe or view archives of postings, go to the Gambia-L Web interface
at: http://maelstrom.stjohns.edu/archives/gambia-l.html
To contact the List Management, please send an e-mail to:
[log in to unmask]
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
|
