Hi,
 I am a lurker on this site and I'd love to see your text file.
Thanks,
 
Robin
 
 
In a message dated 9/16/2009 9:06:18 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time,  
[log in to unmask] writes:

They had  a back and forth debate over the course of a year of so, via the
listserv.  As I recall, they disagreed mostly on fat and salt. At the time, 
I
found  myself siding with Enig/Fallon on the fat, and Cordain on the salt.
Now I'm  no longer so sure about the salt. I don't think Fallon/Enig brought
in  anything about grains or dairy, since it was on a paleo diet list.  I
compiled a single text file of the whole back-and-forth, which I think  I
still have. I could send it to anyone who wants it, or post it to the  list.

On Tue, Sep 15, 2009 at 3:30 PM, Day, Wally  <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

> >I think you might be confusing  one of them with someone else, because 
Mary
> Enig and
> >Sally  Fallon gave a thumbs-down review to The Paleo Diet and I'm not 
aware
>  of them
> >collaborating with Dr. Cordain.
>
> Wasn't  their basic "beef" with the Paleo Diet the fat vs. lean issue? I
>  recall reading the review and through it a bit disingenuous - it seemed  
they
> focused on one facet they disagreed with and then condemned  Cordain and 
the
> diet as a whole (even though it lines up fairly nicely  with most of their
> philosophy). Personally, I think they emphasize  whole grains and milk a 
bit
> too much (I got in a lengthy debate with  one of their followers on 
another
>  list).