Quick Specs
Server:  Dual Pent. II(333mhz) on an Tyan Motherboard(Thunder 2)
           Generic 7.5gig on IDE 1 (ATA 66)Boot drive
           WD 40gig on Matrox Controller(ATA 100)
           OS....Win2k AS
Workstation:  Pent. II(266mhz) on an Asus KN97-X
                  Quantum Bigfoot 4.3gig on IDE 1
                  OS....Win2k Pro
Have run CHKDSK on all these drives and had no reports of errors or
corruptions.


-----Original Message-----
From: PCBUILD - Personal Computer Hardware discussion List
[mailto:[log in to unmask]]On Behalf Of Peter Shkabara
Sent: Sunday, January 05, 2003 12:15 AM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: [PCBUILD] More on WinXP NTFS problems


I have more news on the NTFS/CHKDSK problem under XP. To test this out,
I installed XP on a spare SCSI drive that I connected externally. I then
booted from this drive and ran CHKDSK on the RAID dirves that had given
me trouble. Guess what? There were no problems reported! Running CHKDISK
on the brand new installation on the SCSI drive, however, produced the
same series of index errors I had seen on the RAID system.

It seems that the errors that are reported are possibly fictitious when
CHKDSK is run against the boot drive. However, I did experience actual
corruption when shutting down the system! At this point I am very close
to switching my OS to Linux and using VMWare to run Windows under Linux.

Stay tuned to more on this. I appreciate the feedback some of you have
already given. Windows 2000 users may want to join this test as well,
since some reports indicate that CHKDSK on Win2k was also a bit buggy. I
don't know if CHKDSK or NTFS is to blame, but it is an unsettling
situation in either case.

Peter
------------------------
The NoSpin Group
[log in to unmask]

        The NOSPIN Group provides a monthly newsletter with great
       tips, information and ideas: NOSPIN-L, The NOSPIN Magazine
           Visit our web site to signup: http://freepctech.com

         PCBUILD maintains hundreds of useful files for download
                     visit our download web page at:
                  http://freepctech.com/downloads.shtml