BULLAMANKA-PINHEADS Archives

The listserv where the buildings do the talking

BULLAMANKA-PINHEADS@LISTSERV.ICORS.ORG

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Met History <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
BP - "Preservationists shouldn't be neat freaks." -- Mary D
Date:
Mon, 19 Jun 2000 22:27:06 EDT
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (62 lines)
... from Manhattan to pick up the rental car because we left the car in the
Vineyard a few years ago - Mrs. Sharpshooter is still mad abou that, says
that not having a car in the city makes her feel "trailer park", but I like
getting a new, clean car every time we need one (and not paying $325.00/month
for the garage).

The train ride was neat - west of Philadelphia it's all new country to me.  I
last saw the Harrisburg RR Station when Jim Fitch and I went there around
1980  pursuing a restoration job with a joint venture A/E firm.  Whoever
ultimately got the project did a fair job - the big train shed looks good,
although they left out the architect's name from the plaque in the waiting
room (my bet: Furness & Hewitt, late work).

Stopped at the Pennsylvania State Capitol in Harrisburg, certainly the
absolute worst such interior I've ever seen - an ignorant, bombastic
Klassical, without a hint of subtlety or art, except the peculiar Mercer tile
floor in the rotunda.  The exterior of the dome is in green tile alternating
with gold ribs - kind of neat.

Meandered out towards Fallingwater via local roads, including Munn's Choice,
a little hamlet with a neat old general store ("Munn?  Sorry, never heard of
him.") and the Queen Anne-style "Cosmopolitan Hotel - Now Under Renovation",
although it looks to me that they don't get that many visitors.

Next morning we took the $50 tour of Fallingwater, and I'm afraid my dubious
forebodings were confirmed. (Or maybe I just self-confirmed them.)
Interesting house, but I failed to see any single thing or group of things
which set it much apart from other interesting houses by much-less-branded
designers than Wright. (Examine, for instance, Louis Curtiss' Sutherland
house in Kansas City, or George & Edward Blum's apartment houses in NYC.)  In
fact, if anything, it struck me that the house should be a monument to the
Kaufmanns, not FLW. Turns out they were pretty interesting clients, but that
doesn't sell tickets, I expect.  (I want to see the house they had Benno
Janssen design for them in Pittsburgh in 1930, only 6 years before going over
to FLW.)

Wright's arrogant incompetence in such things as unforgivably demanding
tolerances on the windows, poor reinforcement, uncomfortable furniture,
pointlessly low ceilings and dark halls - the whole thing was an
embarrassment to me - what an abuse of trust and power!

And I hardly agree with Wright's much-bruited opinion that positioning the
house so it would have had a direct view of the waterfall would have
"spoiled" the occupants.  I kept wanting to ask the docent "Just what is this
'organic' architecture, anyway?" during the tour, but they were all
believers.  (Is there balsamic architecture? How about free-range
architecture?  Cruelty-free architecture?)   Upshot: when I make my 4th
$million, I am absolutely not hiring an architect who wears a cape to design
my house-cum-waterfall escape.

Sign me,   prefers George Maher, anyway

We then back-roaded it through all sorts of neat villages - Ohiopyle;
Confluence; Centerville; saw lots of neat barns (local variant: wooden
lattice covers over the barn windows) and wound up in Mercersburg, where
Sharpshooter, Jr., is in summer science camp.  Neat campus, interesting
buildings, rowed up like half of the UVA campus, in different styles - Doric,
Victorian, renaissance.  Plus a retro 1992 library with steep sloping slate
roofs.  I noticed that slate failure on this 8 year old roof was much more
widespread than on a 1927 administration building, a 73 year old one. Perhaps
that's why they didn't list the architect's name in the library handout.

ATOM RSS1 RSS2